These Milky Means cookies are absolutely loaded with melty Milky Means chocolate bars, and additional thick and chewy. The key? Bake your cookies deep-dish-style, in a muffin-top pan!
I selected nougat-and-caramel-filled Milky Means bars, however you may make these cookies with any mix-ins you’d like. And when you love an uber-thick cookie recipe, try my cookie cups filled with Reese’s Cups, subsequent!
The key to those “deep-dish” Milky Means cookies is a muffin top pan, also referred to as a whoopie pan (as a result of you too can use it to bake whoopie pies). One of these pan has shallow wells reasonably than a flat sheet, ensuing within the thickest, soft-baked, chocolate-filled cookies ever. You’ve by no means had a cookie like this earlier than!
*This recipe was initially printed in 2011. The pictures and useful ideas have been up to date in 2025. The recipe stays the identical!
Double the thickness. Even the thickest cookie baked on a baking sheet might solely dream of being as thick and gooey as these Milky Means cookies baked in a muffin high pan.
Smooth and moist. I make these cookies with extra brown sugar than white sugar, in order that they’re additional moist and chewy. Much more so since we go away them barely underbaked, for the right soft-baked texture.
Loaded with chocolate. In case you’re unfamiliar, Milky Means is a sort of sweet bar with nougat smothered with caramel and a layer of milk chocolate. Sure, it’s as indulgent because it sounds. And, sure, it’s the right selection for an extra-thick cookie!
Components You’ll Want
These Milky Means cookies name for a number of simple substances that, collectively, give the cookies the final word chewy texture. Try my notes right here, and scroll right down to the printable recipe card after the put up for the total listing with quantities.
Butter – I all the time bake with salted butter, however you should use unsalted when you choose. Deliver the butter to room temperature earlier than you begin.
Sugar – Identical to my chewy chocolate chip cookies, these Milky Means cookies use each brown sugar and white sugar.
Eggs and Vanilla –The eggs may also be at room temperature.
Dry Components – Baking soda, salt, and all-purpose flour.
Milky Means Bars – I take advantage of the fun-sized bars and chop them roughly. You are able to do the identical with full-size bars. Be at liberty to substitute your selection of sweet bars or chocolate chips if wanted.
The right way to Make Milky Means Cookies
Regardless that we’re baking these Milky Means cookies in a unique form of pan, the strategy to combine the dough is similar as any of my favourite cookie recipes. And when you don’t have a muffin high pan, I’ve you coated with baking sheet directions beneath. Scroll to the recipe card for the printable directions.
Prep. Whereas the oven preheats to 350ºF, coat your muffin high pan with baking spray. Then, place a parchment spherical into the underside of every effectively, and spray once more.
Combine the moist substances.Add the dry substances.
Combine the moist substances. Begin by creaming the butter and sugars collectively, then slowly combine within the eggs and vanilla till mixed.
Add dry substances. With the mixer on low, add the dry substances. Lastly, fold within the Milky Means items simply because the dough comes collectively.
Fold within the Milky Means bars.Fill the pan and bake!
Fill the pan and bake. Press about ¼ cup of cookie dough into every lined effectively. Bake the cookies at 350ºF for 13-Quarter-hour till they’re set on the edges, and nonetheless barely underbaked within the center.
Cool. Let these Milky Means cookies relaxation within the pan for a couple of minutes, then rigorously loosen the perimeters and pop them out onto a wire rack.
Can I Make These as Drop Cookies As a substitute?
Sure! In case you don’t have a muffin high pan, you may bake these Milky Means cookies as common drop cookies on a lined baking sheet. You’ll have to scoop much less dough on this case, about 1 rounded tablespoon per cookie. Bake them for 8-9 minutes at 350ºF, or till the cookies are golden on the edges.
Baking Ideas and Variations
Don’t overbake the cookies. The important thing to soft-baked, thick, and chewy cookies is ensuring that you just don’t overbake them! Leaving cookies within the oven too lengthy causes them to dry out. Pull these Milky Means cookies from the oven once they’re JUST set within the heart. They’ll proceed to arrange within the pan afterward.
Totally different ovens bake in another way. I give a variety for the baking time on this recipe. Since some ovens run hotter than others, I like to recommend checking the cookies on the earliest recommended time (13 minutes for deep-dish cookies, 8 minutes for normal cookies). This avoids overbaking.
Brown the butter. For a fair richer taste in these Milky Means cookies, brown the butter beforehand. You’ll be able to observe the directions in my brown butter chocolate chip cookies recipe.
These Milky Means cookies are additional thick and chewy, baked deep-dish-style in a muffin high pan! They’re loaded with melty Milky Means sweet bars and are critically irresistible.
1 cup butter, room temperature
1 cup darkish brown sugar
1/2 cup granulated sugar
2 giant eggs
2 teaspoons vanilla extract
1 teaspoon baking soda
1 1/2 teaspoon coarse sea salt
2 1/2 cups all-purpose flour
1 (11.24 ounces) bag of fun-sized Milky Means bars, chopped
Preheat oven to 350°F.
Put together your muffin pan by first spraying with cooking spray, subsequent lining every tin with a parchment spherical. (Reduce the parchment to slot in the underside of the pan) after which spraying the parchment once more evenly. Put aside.
Combine the butter and sugars collectively in your stand mixer fitted with the paddle attachment for two minutes. Add within the eggs, vanilla, baking soda, and sea salt and blend for 30 seconds, or till mixed and clean, scraping the perimeters of the bowl as essential.
Flip the mixer to low and add within the flour. When simply blended collectively, fold in your chopped Milky Means.
Press 1/4 cup the cookie dough into every muffin high and bake for 13-Quarter-hour till the perimeters are golden and the middle is JUST set.
Take away from oven and let cool in pan for five minutes. Loosen the perimeters with a knife and flip the cookies onto a wire cooling rack.
Notes
In case you make these with out utilizing a muffin high pan, line your baking sheet with parchment paper or a Silpat. House the cookies out 2 inches aside and drop by rounded tablespoons onto the baking sheet. Bake for 8-9 minutes till edges are golden.
This recipe makes roughly 12-15 “deep-dish” cookies, or 24 common drop cookies (large-size).
